Usamah Harvey
The film's masterful storytelling did its job. The message was clear. No need to overdo.
Aneesa Wardle
The story, direction, characters, and writing/dialogue is akin to taking a tranquilizer shot to the neck, but everything else was so well done.
Matylda Swan
It is a whirlwind of delight --- attractive actors, stunning couture, spectacular sets and outrageous parties.
Celia
A great movie, one of the best of this year. There was a bit of confusion at one point in the plot, but nothing serious.
Jim Tritten
Its been a long time since I watched a Hopalong feature film. This one kind of surprised me. The plot was more complex than the average horse opera. The acting is what you would expect of this type genre and funding. There were some surprisingly well-done shots by the camera as well. All in all, much higher rated than those who said it lacked this and that. Not a great movie, but one I would submit is about as good as it gets for this type movie. Hoppy actually has a serious interest in the girl ... but still rides off into the sunset with his buddies and his horse.
JohnHowardReid
Attractively photographed (Russell Harlan) but lifeless Hopalong Cassidy. All the action occurs in the space of two or three minutes at the finale. Not that it's over-exciting anyway! The rest of the film is very, very dull. At least Cassidy of Bar 20, unimpressive as the feature itself might be, made a fine trailer. Running a mere 137 feet (that's exactly 1½ minutes), this preview is much the usual "thriller", containing plenty of action - fast-riding cowboys, gun-play, comedy and romance. To quote Paramount publicity: "Opens with thrilling scene of cowboys riding across the range... amusing scene as Cassidy and Darien are held up by Margaret Marquis... dramatic scene between Nora Lane and Boyd... thrilling interlude as Boyd threatens men in store... cowboys riding to the round-up of killers... introduction of all players in characteristic poses... and many other exciting scenes."Oh, yeah? Well where are these "many exciting scenes"! On the cutting-room floor or simply in the press book editor's imagination?
bkoganbing
Cassidy Of Bar 20 has two things unique in the series. I only recall one other time that actual personality from the old west is in a Hoppy movie as a character. One was a later Belle Starr story and in this one Clay Allison makes an appearance. However the real Allison assuredly no boy scout was not anything like the rat we see in this film.The other is that Frank Darien makes his one and only appearance as the old timer sidekick for Hoppy. There were a few before producer Harry Sherman settled on Andy Clyde after Gabby Hayes left. He was just simply Pappy and he rode a mule. He never really took and I can see why Sherman just used him once and that was that.Allison is making trouble for small ranchers like John Elliott and his wife who had some history with Hoppy sends for him. Allison is played by Robert Fiske and he's not got much in the way of character. He does a couple of cold blooded murders in Cassidy Of Bar 20 and pays in the end.Hoppy fans should like this. Belle Starr made out better in a Hoppy movie, Clay Allison far worse.
chipe
This is one of the worst Hoppy films. The plot was unbelievable and weak. The comic sidekick (Frank Darien as Pappy) was also among the worst in the series. ***Spoliers.*** Hoppy is out to help his girl friend whose ranch is being rustled and preyed upon by local rustlers-land grabbers, led by Clay Allison. For no good workable reason (from my viewpoint) Hoppy lets himself get arrested and imprisoned for trespassing (or whatever), and then he convinces Allison to put Hoppy on parole and work his time out at Allison's ranch. In short order, Hoppy sees Allison's men maybe rustling Nora's cattle. So Hoppy rides off to see Nora. (What about his parole agreement?) Meanwhile, Fred is the only witness to see Allison shoot Nora's partner (or foreman) dead. For no real good reason that I could see, Fred's mom suspects her son as involved in the murder and has the son placed in jail! None of this really matters because Allison finally decides to have his gang descend on Hoppy and everyone else at Nora's ranch, but they are beaten back and Allison is killed.Not much of a good plot.