Inclubabu Plot so thin, it passes unnoticed.

PodBill Just what I expected

Payno I think this is a new genre that they're all sort of working their way through it and haven't got all the kinks worked out yet but it's a genre that works for me.

Edwin The storyline feels a little thin and moth-eaten in parts but this sequel is plenty of fun.

TKBlackburn This was the most fun reality show ever. It had everything. The problem...a mentally unstable contestant who committed suicide shortly after her departure from the show (more related to her boyfriend's death than leaving the show apparently). They quietly took the show off the air & showed the final episodes online only. Buried it completely. No one ever talked about it.It's been 10 years since the unfortunate off-camera drama unfolded, & while it can have a different name & new host to give it a fresh start, it was set up so well that I can't see it failing.I hope they bring it back.

a-darby One of the most original and entertaining reality TV program's I have ever watched. The way that the contestants had to pit their wits against others and had to judge other contestants made this a kill or be killed scenario and very entertaining to watch. I am so sorry that the Americans binned this after just 1 series. As usual if they are not the best they discard instead of giving it a chance. An Emmy award says just how good it was, in my eyes only Dexter and Game of Thrones has come close to it for entertainment. Had this been a GB series this would have been given longer than the one series and would by now be a cult show. Regards A. PS. Another series please!

Linda_S CBS had a winner, from an artistic and entertainment standpoint, in Pirate Master. I don't know exactly WHY CBS canceled this outstanding entry in the reality genre but alas this superb show is now history. Big Brother, Survivor PALE IN COMPARISON to Pirate Master. I loved the costumes, I loved the ship, I loved the islands, the ocean, the crew, and Captain Azmyth. There was everything wonderful in this show from scenery to the Captain using his sword to cast adrift the person voted off the ship each week. I wish CBS would reconsider, it is not fair to those of us who tuned in eagerly each week it was on and enjoyed it so immensely. Frankly it was so far above in intrigue and interest of all the other reality type shows combined that I am really quite upset. I hope it can be released on DVD at least.

bgingras-1 Survivor on a boat. the ship that is CBS is sinking fast, the liferafts are filling up with viewers heading to safety in huge numbers. This is truly bad. No wonder it debut with such low ratings...This is "Un-Reality" at it's worst, well until kid nation debuts anyway.Realty TV has come, it took it's ratings, and it's viewers and it's time has passed. To repackage survivor in pirate costumes is simply bad. CBS is grasping at straws and nearing the end of the plank. CBS needs to step up and pay attention to it's viewer before they have no viewers to pay attention to.CBS needs to bring back Jericho and stop "experimenting" with this trash, half scripted, garbage.