SoftInloveRox Horrible, fascist and poorly acted

Tedfoldol everything you have heard about this movie is true.

Roman Sampson One of the most extraordinary films you will see this year. Take that as you want.

Payno I think this is a new genre that they're all sort of working their way through it and haven't got all the kinks worked out yet but it's a genre that works for me.

He_who_lurks This Lumiere documentary is again nothing special or ground-breaking from anything else we've seen but it's entertaining because it shows a moment in time. There's a little girl (somebody named Madeleine Koehler, a friend of the Lumiere family, maybe?) who is in her highchair, with a cat perched on the tray, diving for the food she holds in her hand. The film ends just as the cat dives for the girl's hand. I have to say the composition is excellent and the well-placed camera captures the activity decently. There is plenty of action within the frame as well. For what it is it's nothing special, and I'm not sure if this was staged. Maybe so. While not something overly special or interesting, it's a Lumiere actuality just capturing what happened between 'the little girl and her cat' so you can't criticize it for what it was trying to do. Since I'm a big fan of these Lumiere actualities I of course liked it. Even today's audiences might find this to be a cute little film.

Michael_Elliott La petite fille et son chat (1899)Louis Lumiere directed this picture which shows a little girl sitting in her chair trying to feed a cat. At first the cat appears willing but he then jumps off only to be thrown back on the girl. These early films sometimes just had directors turning the camera on hoping to catch something special. This is a pretty fun film to watch because the cat eventually gets more interested in what's going on and at one point the girl takes the food away only to have the cat use its paws to try and get it back. There's certainly nothing ground-breaking here but it's an entertaining film that even today's audiences would enjoy.

Horst in Translation (filmreviews@web.de) This is an 1899 French silent black-and-white movie by Louis Lumière, one of the most known filmmakers of the very early days. It only runs for 40 seconds and we basically see a little girl feeding her cat. The cat gets a bite, jumps away, but returns quickly for more food. What I found most memorable was the way the little girl was dressed here, very extravagantly and pretty much like a grown-up woman. I did not like it. But the cat was pretty cute and majestic at the same time. Looks like it became more popular to film animals. There are other movies out there with horses, bulls, cats, birds etc from that time. Unfortunately, apart from the cute cat there is no other reason for watching this. Decide for yourself if this is reason enough. I would recommend it to cat lovers only.

F Gwynplaine MacIntyre A little girl sits at a table, holding a container of what appears to be some sort of food. Suddenly there's a flash of movement: a tortoiseshell cat, with long hair and a very furry tail, has leapt onto the table. The girl and the cat are clearly friends: she cheerfully feeds the cat little bits of whatever's in that container.I couldn't get a good look at the food: it really looks more like tea leaves than anything else. Some of the Lumiere films are of vital historic significance, serving as visual records of the clothes, buildings and human activities of their time. 'The Little Girl and Her Cat' serves no great purpose except to establish that (shock surprise!) cats of the late 19th century look and behave the same as cats of our own period. And are just as hungry, I'll be bound. Nothing especially interesting here, folks ... although this probably fascinated audiences back in 1899.