Softwing Most undeservingly overhyped movie of all time??

Smartorhypo Highly Overrated But Still Good

Merolliv I really wanted to like this movie. I feel terribly cynical trashing it, and that's why I'm giving it a middling 5. Actually, I'm giving it a 5 because there were some superb performances.

Sarita Rafferty There are moments that feel comical, some horrific, and some downright inspiring but the tonal shifts hardly matter as the end results come to a film that's perfect for this time.

Pigbelly This movie is a cinematic collage of gangster clichés. The writing is grade z and the plot and story are constructed without care or logic. It a messy pastiche of stereotypical gangsters (think of Bugs Bunny cartoons) and silly supporting characters (the lady doctor and the writer). There are much better Bogart films out there. In fact, Bogart looks like he slept through this performance. He puts very little effort into this character. I think the directorial advice he received was something like "He's a bad guy. Act bad". This guy is the era's equivalent of Darth Vader; obvious, evil and the anti-hero. Don't waste your time with this one.

theowinthrop I wonder if the screenwriter for this film had somebody in mind as a model for the criminal Humphrey Bogart plays. In the 1920s and 1930s there was a major war between Joe Masseria and Salvator Marranzano for control of New York's criminal underworld. Marranzano, on the surface, seemed more modern to the younger crowd of gangsters like Luciano, Costello, Siegel, Lansky, and Lepke, and they helped him get rid of the "Mustache Petes" or old style gangsters supporting Masseria (and eventually Masseria himself). But they found that rather than restructuring the criminal world into a model corporate structure, Marranzano had delusions of grandeur. He was intoxicated by the image and memory of Gaius Julius Caesar, and intended to make himself the Caesar of the New York Underworld. Eventually "Caesar" Marranzano was bumped off by the disgruntled young Turks who did not plan for him to be a "Capo di Capo".Interestingly enough he was stabbed to death in his office - one wonders if Luciano and the others purposely copied Caesar's demise in the forum. In this remake of an early Paul Muni film, DR. SOCRATES, Kay Francis is a female doctor who discovers that her late husband was tied to a powerful mobster (Bogart) and got killed helping him with some medical attention for one of his gang. The police and A.D.A. (Pierre Watkins) arrest and try Francis on really weak grounds as an accomplice, but the jury is deadlocked and she is released while the A.D.A. decides whether or not to retry her. Francis is determined to prove her innocence by catching Bogart.Humphrey Bogart played many gangsters in the 1930s, and most of them were quite dangerous types, like Duke Mantee in THE PETRIFIED FOREST or Baby Face Martin in DEAD END. But his gangster boss here is ridiculous. The reason is that the screenwriter created a personality point about this gangster that is never pursued properly in the film. Bogart is enamored by the career of Napoleon Bonaparte, and keeps mentioning this. Never once in the course of the film, outside an occasional reference to say Waterloo or some incident like that, do we see Bogie trying to use Napoleons aphorisms and strategies in his crimes! For example, Bonaparte once dismissed military brilliance and said something to the effect that he preferred "lucky" generals to brilliant ones. He realized that a brilliant general could get so hung up about his own brilliant schemes that he could blow a major battle, whereas a "lucky" general looks quickly at a situation and grabs the initiative. Bogart does not show any inclination to follow that particular piece of wisdom, and does not even mention it.Bogart also is never shown using any of the strategies that made Marengo or Austerlitz or Jena victories that rang down through the last two centuries in his robbery schemes or crimes. For a man who supposedly admires a great figure he doesn't seem willing to learn from him!In the plot Francis hides in a small town and Bogart shows up there to rescue two of his men from the local police (actually similar to an incident involving gangster John Dillinger). Bogart has also picked up a traveling writer (James Stephenson) who he realizes can ghost write Bogies criminal memoirs. Stephenson is arrested in the incident, but he is released into Francis' custody (she is now a doctor in the town), and subsequently kidnapped by Bogie (not quite like the unfortunate Duc de Enghien). Soon Francis is in pursuit, and notes Bogies health as a potential key to undermining his control of her fate and Stephenson's. It involves giving him a peculiar drug that has to be also given to all his men at the same time to disable them all. This part of the script is absolutely unbelievable as Bogie's gangster does not accept the simple solution of selecting one of his men as a guinea pig to test the drug on (Francis manages to browbeat him into taking the drug!).There are elements of other, better films in KING OF THE UNDERWORLD. Most notable is James Stephenson's writer/hobo who resembles Leslie Howard's in THE PETRIFIED FOREST. The acting is pretty good (best are the scenes involving the local bigwig doctor who resents the arrival of Francis in the small town, and starts making problems for her). Stephenson was a fine young actor, whose best role (the troubled barrister defending Bette Davis' "Leslie Crosby" in THE LETTER) was yet to come, and his death in the early 1940s was a true loss to movies. Francis does nicely in her role, even if her victory over Bogie is asinine. Bogie is good - wish I could say the same for his character or the script.

sol **SPOILER ALERT** Remake of the 1935 Paul Muni comedy crime drama "Doctor Socrates" but a lot more violent with Humphrey Bogart as the delusional crime boss Joe Gurney. Gurney envisions himself as being the Napoleon of the underworld and uses the 19th century French Emperors same strategy of conducting wars to him conducting his gang of hoodlums.Gurney seeing that Dr. Niles Nelson,John Eldredge, did such a good job in patching up one of his gang members offer him a job as his personal physician paying Dr. Nelson as much as $500.00 a visit. All is good and well until the Doc gets gunned down in a police raid as he was treating one of Gurney's hoods. That leaves his totally Innocent wife who's also a doctor, Carole ,Kay Francis, not only wearing the paths in the Nelson family but suspected by the police as being a doctor for the mob and in danger of losing her license to practice medicine.Setting up a practice in the little town of Wayne Center Carole feels that Gurney and his boys will be paying her, or Wayne Center, a visit with one of his gang members being in the town jail. Carole doesn't have to wait too long with the Gurney gang rolling into town the very next day and springing their man from prison. During the violent shoot-out a man in one of Gurney's attack cars is seen fleeing from the scene and shot. The man is later found out not to be a member of Gurney's gang but down and out English writer Bill Stevens, James Stephenson. It turns out that Stevens hitched or was taken for a ride, with him having no say in the matter, with the Gurney Gang not at first knowing that Gurney was the notorious fugitive from the law that he is.Treated by Carole in his prison cell Stevens is later kidnapped by the Gurney Gang in not that he knows that much about their boss' whereabouts but that he was in the process of writing Gurney's autobiography as the man who made it to the top of the heap, in the world of US crime.During the prison breakout Gurney was also hit suffering a nasty bullet wound on his right arm and had two of his hoods kidnap Carole bringing her to their hideout outside town to treat it. Carole does an excellent job dressing and disinfecting Gurney's bullet wound yet the "I don't take orders from a dame" Gurney doesn't take care of himself. This has him get very ill with a high fever from the wound getting reinfected that Gurney has Carole re-kidnapped and taken back again to his hideout in order to treat it.Seeing her chance to help the police and prove that she isn't a member of Gurney's gang Carole has Gurney think that he contacted a serious case of Streptococci on top of all that he also infected his entire gang. Telling the now scared sh*tless Gurney that she'll have to go back to her doctors office and get this ointment to save him and his gang from going blind, due to the Streptococci infection. Carole then secretly tips off the police to not only where Gurney's hideout is but that by midnight, when the ointment that she's to give him and his boys will take effect, they'll all be as blind as a bat and ripe to take into custody without any problem. Carole was only half right with Gurney & Co. going blind but at the same time not going easy but down in a hail of bullets.

kyle_furr This was almost as bad as return of Dr. X. Bogart made some pretty crappy films in the late 30's, but he also made some good ones. The only thing worth saying is that Bogart kept talking about napoleon. Don't waste your time, watch dead end or marked woman instead.