Seraherrera The movie is wonderful and true, an act of love in all its contradictions and complexity

Siflutter It's easily one of the freshest, sharpest and most enjoyable films of this year.

Stephanie There is, somehow, an interesting story here, as well as some good acting. There are also some good scenes

Dana An old-fashioned movie made with new-fashioned finesse.

namashi_1 'Khamoshiyan' rides on a stunning premise, but what is eventually served, is under-whelming. The sole saving grace is its melodious music. 'Khamoshiyan' Synopsis: An erotic love triangle revolving around a writer adrift in the icy slopes of Kashmir where he discovers a woman with a strange, silent past.The problem with 'Khamoshiyan' is its Screenplay Written by Vikram Bhatt. It's so confused between being an erotica and a horror/thriller, that it never achieves its aim. Despite a few spine-chilling moments in the first-hour, the second-hour is devoid of scares or thrills. How one wishes if Bhatt simply concentrated on just one particular genre. Karan Darra's Direction is claustrophobic. Cinematography captures some moments well. Editing is fair. Music by Various Artists, is fabulous. Each & Every song is melodious. Performance-Wise: Ali Faizal is earnest, but not memorable! Sapna Pabbi looks gorgeous, but is leaps away from being called an actress. Gurmeet Chaudhary hams. He's more funny, than being vicious. On the whole, 'Khamoshiyan' is a great idea, gone wrong.

seher khan the movie is a good one. Its worth watching. Music is very sensational and deep. Acting also goes well. Erotic scenes are well but could be more. I love the first half of the movie. It is a fun filled pack overall. Ali goes well. The girl also has one well. Loved watching it. I enjoyed watching it. Especially the erotic scenes and the music holds the attention. The girl has tried her best to do well. Her husband's role is also performed very well, but there could be some space for more for him.I watched it and enjoyed whole of the time. It is a worth watching movie, but still has some confusions at the end, which i was unable to understand. Bheeg loon track is the best of all songs.

Dhruv Naik Khamoshiyan is first film of Gurmeet Choudhary and Sapna Pabbi.No one will say that this is the first movie of Karan Darra as director.Music is composed by Jeet Ganguly and Ankit Tiwari and its superb.Ali Fazal as kabir as novel writer with grey shades has done a nice job.Gurmeet Choudhary is playing negative role as Jaidev.He is probably good in all scenes but impressive in post interval sequences.Sapna Pabbi is so stunning and hot in some sequences.Vikram Bhatt who has written the story of the movie will be seen as Ali's friend and book editor.Overall,after long time bollywood gave a nice horror flick.1st half is engaging and leave you in interval with so many questions.2nd half could have been much better.I'll go with 5.5/10.

Bobish Mp Its very sad to see such mockery in the genre "Horror",( sorry they don't need horror no longer, they got a sub genre called erotic horror/erotic thriller or simply horrex)..The most pathetic fact is that we will get even more better story from some old B grade horror films..Scare, sex the pattern is itself repeating, and be honest it disappoints by all the way.. The plot is very ridiculous and unbelievable.. Why they are repeating the tested formula of "Main stream B grade" films..I don't want to say the story, you can guess it ! What was so raunchy and erotic in the movie that it got an A certificate? At once you would be clueless seeing Sapna Pabbi stripping off and then Ali Fazal trying to make love to her in the very first meet!! Don't waste your time by watching this so called horror film! One minute silence please!