Cathardincu Surprisingly incoherent and boring

CommentsXp Best movie ever!

Michelle Ridley The movie is wonderful and true, an act of love in all its contradictions and complexity

Staci Frederick Blistering performances.

JohnHowardReid Copyright 17 March 1950 by Universal Pictures Co., Inc. New York opening at Loew's Criterion: 26 March 1950. U.S. release: March 1950. U.K. release through General Film Distributors: 13 March 1950. Australian release: 13 July 1950. 6,916 feet. 77 minutes.COMMENT: With a pirate hero who isn't too bloodthirsty and a villain who isn't too villainous, Buccaneer's Girl is a perfect contender for kiddies' matinees. No disadvantage either in its cargo of character players - or its script of pure drivel. Miss De Carlo "sings" in this one, but she does look great in period costumes - many thanks to Russell Metty's loving camerawork. Maestro Metty also richly embellishes De Cordova's competently ordinary direction, as well as the sets. Love the shot of Norman Lloyd in his black cloak.Lloyd of course makes a delicious henchman for our favorite villain Robert Douglas, who is in great form here. Alas, some of our other idols are not so well treated. Douglass Dumbrille is confined to a brief appearance at the beginning. We keep waiting for him to come back, but no luck. Maybe he was busy that day at M-G-M. John Qualen and Connie Gilchrist are also saddled with small spots in which they have no opportunities to shine. Henry Daniell is likewise wasted. Luckily, Elsa Lanchester has a decent part. As for Philip Friend, well he's much your usual third-string Stewart Granger. We can take him or leave him. All the same, there's a fair amount of action, including fist fights and swordplay. Plus nice color. Despite the silly story and its cruel waste of much acting talent, at least Buccaneer's Girl knows when its audience has had enough. Unlike most 2005 films, it doesn't run too long.

mark.waltz Sultry Yvonne De Carlo is the entire show in this colorful adventure that shows that women could be as tough as men when they needed to be, yet soft and feminine when it was time to return to being a woman. She stows away on a passenger ship, is taken to New Orleans by pirates, goes to work for a bordello madam, slaps a few society dames silly, ends up back on a pirate ship and ultimately gets a sword in her hand. It's all pretty silly stuff, and Yvonne, a more talented rival to Maria Montez, saves the day. Only rivaled perhaps by Maureen O'Hara when it comes to sultry female masculinity, is not going to be treated with disrespect. She stands up to madam Elsa Lanchaster, beats the crap out of disrespectful snob Andrea King, and wins the love of a handsome hero, Philip Friendly. A ton of familiar character actors make nice additions, including Douglas Dumbrille, Henry Daniell, Connie Gilchrist, Verna Felton and lesser known black character actress Hattie Noel, briefly singing a song about pralines. Ms. Noel had me in stitches as Joan Blondell's companion in the camp classic "Lady For a Night", and did a neat little shimmy to "Alice Blue Gown" in a film version of "Irene". De Carlo sings a few songs here, although I didn't recognize her voice as being the same as she did when she sang "I'm Still Here!" in "Follies". The film succeeds mainly on her personality, a delightfully manipulative ploy to make it appear better than it is.

MARIO GAUCI When this swashbuckling DVD set was announced, I was rather annoyed about the inclusion of three obscure efforts with the popular and vintage AGAINST ALL FLAGS (1952) starring Errol Flynn; well, having watched all three now, this proved to be perhaps the most resistible of them. For the record, my copy jumps from the Universal logo (preceding all their DVD releases) to the beginning of the film omitting the credits entirely, then it pixellated terribly around the 64-minute mark, so that I had to skip to the next chapter (thus missing a couple of minutes) in order to keep watching the thing through to its conclusion! The plot has a New Orleans setting with a pirate named Baptiste (Philip Friend, an unknown actor to me but an okay lead under the circumstances) who hides under the guise of an aristocrat in order to keep up the fight with chief villain Robert Douglas (aided in his nefarious deeds by two other notable character actors – Norman Lloyd and Henry Daniell). Guttersnipe Yvonne de Carlo – I recall watching her other swashbuckler with director de Cordova, THE DESERT HAWK (1950), as a child – and upper-class Andrea King vie for the dashing Friend's attentions (at one point, the two let their hair down and engage in a catfight over him during a ball!), while Jay C. Flippen appears as the hero's right-hand man. Incidentally, having seen this immediately after DOUBLE CROSSBONES (1951), it was amusing to realize that some of the sea-battle footage from BUCCANEER'S GIRL was replicated wholesale into the Donald O'Connor vehicle! The film itself would be tolerable enough if it weren't for two huge flaws: for one thing, the action-less climax has to be the lamest ever devised for this type of fare; much more queasy, unfortunately, are de Carlo's trio of songs (under the tutelage of typically eccentric Elsa Lanchester) – with the last of them occurring just minutes before the end titles! – and for which the creator of the embarrassingly corny choreography ought to have been made to walk the plank himself.

copper1963 Handsomely mounted Yvonne De Carlo potboiler from Universal-International, which perfectly showcases a bygone era of bloodthirsty pirates and snooty aristocrats. Phillip Friend secures and flourishes in the dual roles of Captain Kingston and the cutthroat Baptiste. He has just the right amount of swagger and glint in his eye to pull it off. I like how Kingston supports the "Seaman's Fund" with his stolen booty. He is very much like a 19th century version of Robin Hood. But it's all quite unbelievable, really. Can he keep his identity a secret from the elites? Well, Miss De Carlo knows his true identity, and it's "Baptiste/Kingston's job to convince her of his own sincerity and goodwill. As for De Carlo's "Debbie McCoy," she sings three songs (and dances), gets into five scrapes, and exhibits a high degree of skill for escaping dire predicaments. She radiates a keen comedic flair for the broad material. While watching this movie, I developed a feeling that she reminded me of someone else. But I couldn't place the thought until she is caught napping in a shopkeeper's vegetable closet. She chews on a carrot, roles her eyes, and strolls confidently away from the prickly situation involving the storekeeper, his jealous wife, and a constable. And the actress she reminded me of: Lucille Ball. She's that talented here.