Tetrady not as good as all the hype

Chirphymium It's entirely possible that sending the audience out feeling lousy was intentional

SeeQuant Blending excellent reporting and strong storytelling, this is a disturbing film truly stranger than fiction

Zandra The movie turns out to be a little better than the average. Starting from a romantic formula often seen in the cinema, it ends in the most predictable (and somewhat bland) way.

wes-connors Swimming heiress Annette Kellerman (as Shona Royal) is the "most skillful diver in the South Seas. As "swift and sure as any creature of the water," Ms. Kellerman is the captain of her father's pearling fleet. She lives with daddy Roland Purdie (as John Royal) and numerous native servants, on their island paradise "Manea". The Royals deal with snaky supply ship captain Norman French (as John Drake), who encourages their natives to steal, by buying their booty. Later, Mr. French will cause trouble on ship. Before all that, Kellerman falls in love with passing pleasure cruiser Robert Ramsey (as Robert Quane Jr.). Mr. Ramsey is so smitten with Kellerman, he may give up his playboy lifestyle! Kellerman's best film was the lost epic "A Daughter of the Gods", a spectacular hit upon release and reissued into the 1920s; but, unfortunately, no copy has surfaced for present inspection. Kellerman still looks incredibly fit, but "Venus of the South Seas" is not really a good representation. She was, likely, not an "actress" as much as a celebrity, causing a sensation by appearing in a shocking (at the time) "one piece" bathing suit; and, later, appearing nude on film. No nudity in "Venus", which is mildly notable for some colorful underwater footage.**** Venus of the South Seas (2/24) James R. Sullivan ~ Annette Kellerman, Robert Ramsey, Norman French

JohnHowardReid Despite its interesting use of color tints, the charm of its real locations and some reasonable acting in the support cast, the last of Miss Kellerman's feature-length movies (and the only one that is available in complete form in 2008) proves something of a disappointment. The first problem lies in Miss Kellerman herself. She is, to put it kindly, a ham of the first water. Her only rival in the scenery-chewing department would be John Barrymore at his worst.Okay, so we're not watching the film to see fine acting, but simply to view the legendary Annette Kellerman in her prime. Well, this aspect is none too bright either. Miss Kellerman has aged a little since she frolicked around as a mermaid in "Neptune's Daughter" (1914), and although she is still a top-hole diver and swimmer, her figure is a little chunky, or at least a little too muscular by 2008 standards of feminine beauty.Never mind that! What about the swimming and the underwater ballet fantasy? Well, that's a bit of a letdown too. I guess I was expecting something akin to the Esther Williams' re-enactments in "Million Dollar Mermaid" (1952). This sequence here is brightly colored, but long and repetitious.Oddly, the best thing about the movie is not Miss Kellerman, not the swimming and underwater sequences, not the location scenery, but the old-hat plot! True, Robert Ramsey makes a dull hero (his career lasted only two films), but Australian actor Norman French puts a bit of life into his villain, and director Sullivan himself (Miss Kellerman's real-life husband) is very personable and charismatic as the first mate.

jennyp-2 Australian swimming sensation Annette Kellerman is remembered today thanks to the biopic Million Dollar Mermaid starring Esther Williams. Once thought a lost film, Venus of the South Seas was recently restored by the Library of Congress. This film has historical significance for the use of primza color in some underwater scenes and generous use of tinting and toning throughout and the new print was stunning. However, the melodramatic plot was tedious, the direction (by Kellerman's husband James R. Sullivan) was clunky and as an actress, Kellerman was a great swimmer. I was glad to see it, but once was enough. Viewed at Cinesation in Massillon Ohio in October 2004.