Inclubabu
Plot so thin, it passes unnoticed.
Marketic
It's no definitive masterpiece but it's damn close.
Lancoor
A very feeble attempt at affirmatie action
runamokprods
Very moving and powerful look at both the caste system and the treatment of women as objects in rural India, in the early 1950s. A young woman from the serf class is taken in and slowly seduced by her arrogant, handsome young "master" whose house she keeps. But when she becomes pregnant, and his promised child bride finally becomes old enough to join him in the house, our heroine is slowly, painfully pushed aside and locked out. The film is occasionally heavy handed in its politics, but the truth behind the story makes the slightly agit-prop nature forgivable. This has none of the singing, dancing and theatrics we have come to associate with modern Indian cinema. This hearkens back to the stark, quiet realism of Satyajit Ray, with complex characters and surprising subtlety.
sashank_kini-1
Surya (Anant Nag) reluctantly becomes the landlord of his father's fields, after his requests to continue further studies are rejected by his father. Surya's father wants him to be financially sound and socially secure, and so gets him married to a young Saroj. Saroj, still a kid, stays back at her house till she comes of age.Meanwhile, Surya stays in the village, where he acquaints Laxmi, the domestic help and her deaf-mute husband Kishtaya, who had been a potter once but was unemployed now. Surya sets things straight in the fields by cutting off the water supplies to his step-mother and step-brother and also ordering the local caretaker to find out who is behind the theft of the juice from the trees. Kishtaya, who is provided the job of taking the village kids to school, turns out to be the culprit and is publicly flayed. He leaves the village without informing anyone, and his wife, Laxmi is left alone with Surya. Surya, being sexually frustrated, makes advances to her and she at last succumbs. Things turn out for the worse when she gets pregnant with his baby and Surya's wife comes to the village to stay with him.Shabana Azmi is a fine and consistent actress and here too she brings temperance to her performance. The scene of compunction is performed with great sincerity and humanness. The same scene could've been ruined with pretentious overacting but under Shyam Benegal's guidance, everything at least looks real. The supporting cast also put truthfulness in their performances, something that I prefer. Usually, I do not like sappiness and I find it a lot in Indian films.The background is verdant and glowing; my favorite color green is frequently seen in the form of grass and trees. Shyam Benegal's direction is cogent, and there are many scenes which touch upon a number of issues prevalent in those times and even now, especially the disturbing attitude of villagers towards caste and the position of women.The movie lacks in completeness, however. One can see a feministic approach Benegal has given here, since Shabana takes up quite a lot of screen time and is also given a mind of her own. But I felt that unfair justice was given to the story in its entirety, mainly because of the excessive focus on Priya Tendulkar's character rather than Shabana's towards the end. It would've been better to keep the direct focus on Anant Nag and Azmi and their characters' behavior towards each other with the coming of Priya's character, who should've got indirect focus. Also, the film does not consider Surya's father's character at the end and ends abruptly with all the blame being put at Surya. I, as a viewer, wanted an ending that was satisfactory for all the characters, as I felt Surya here was not a villain, but just a coward. An example of a perfect climax and catharsis would be 'The Passage to India', which is longer yet more satisfying.Ankur to me is a good film, better than most Indian films today, but not at par with my other Hindi favorites, Pyaasa and Kora Kaagaz ( the Jaya Bachchan movie).My Rating: 6.5/10
Peter Young
Ankur is Shyam Benegal's first movie and amongst all his gems, this is one of those his name will be most associated with. The film was a unique feature of its time - real, poetic, genuine and disturbing. It did not have the songs, the melodrama, and the exaggeration one was used to see in Hindi movies. Instead it had an unusual and gripping storyline portrayed with striking maturity and realism. This film actually established a new genre within the Hindi film industry at the time, commonly known as 'New Wave Cinema', while today people use to describe it as 'Parallel Cinema'. The film was not only special in the way it was treated, but the story itself seemed to have tackled themes which till date are categorised as social taboos in Indian cinema, whether it's adultery or sexual frustration. The film's writers use symbolism to convey the story and many interesting paradoxes and ironies.Ankur tells the story of Lakshmi, a young and serious village woman who works as a housemaid in the landlord's house and who is married to a deaf-mute man who keeps drinking. She sets on an affair with the landlord's son, Surya, who came to the village on his father's insistence to run the family business. From the very beginning of his staying there, he gets very attracted to Lakshmi. After being accused of stealing, Lakshmi's husband gets publicly humiliated by the villagers and later disappears. That's when Lakshmi and Surya's interaction grows and becomes constant. Their relationship, however, ends soon as Surya's young bride comes home. Lakshmi finds out that she is pregnant and Surya refuses to accept her, as he has also been persuaded by his wife to throw her out. A pregnant Lakshmi finds herself all alone struggling for survival, until one day her husband returns with a clear intention to make amends, very happy to find his wife's state but little knowing that he is not her child's father. Benegal's direction is outstanding. He captures the rustic, simple and raw atmosphere of the village with all its cultural customs which would seem peculiar to people not familiar with this kind of lifestyle. He just pays attention to the smallest of details, and that's what makes it so extremely realistic. Whether it's the serene narrative style, the way the proceedings are unfolded, or the way the characters are brought out on screen, all these aspects contribute to this and manage to make the film tense and thrilling. The character of Lakshmi, for instance, is presented as an extraordinary beauty amongst the many ordinary-looking people in the movie, and the viewer can really see why a bored Surya can't take his eyes off her. Ankur is very matter-of-fact in its depiction. It is brutally honest and not even once does it feel sugarcoated or unconvincing. The film's dialogues are fantastic, especially those towards the end.The brightest spot of this movie and the main reason it tugs at your heartstrings is unquestionably Shabana Azmi's powerhouse performance. Ankur is actually her first role, and it still ranks amongst the finest works of her illustrious career. Portraying her role with depth and sincerity, Azmi manages to convey a lot with just sitting silent in front of the camera. Her facial expressions, body language and line delivery are exemplary. Lakshmi draws the audience's sympathy despite being pretty unlikable. She hardly smiles once throughout the film, and looks indifferent to her surroundings, yet the viewers may really feel for her as they see her despair, her non-verbal pain and grief, her inner conflict, her daily struggles and ultimately her conscience and guilt feelings. It goes without saying that Azmi's emotional outbursts towards the end are superbly acted and moving. This one is an all-time great performance by a talent that is even greater.Apart from Azmi who owns the show from start to finish, the acting in the movie is roundly natural. Anant Nag as Surya does a very good job. Sadhu Meher is excellent as Lakshmi's helpless and loving husband. Priya Tendulkar too performs well. The last few scenes of the movie are very intense and heartbreaking. The ending is by far one of the best endings I've seen in a Hindi film - meaningful, unusual and thought-provoking - descriptions which would be perfectly used to describe the film itself. Ankur, to put it simply in just a few words, is one gem of a movie.
golem3
Ankur is literally one the best Indian movies I have ever seen actually, it ranks as one of my most favorite films of all time. There is something to be said about the Indian Film Industry while it has altogether crumbled and become wildly glamorous and crass, many of the Indian movies since the advent of cinema and up until the early eighties were stupendous, thought provoking, and wholly a testament to the power of film.Ankur takes place in rural Andhra Pradesh, where a young man fights his father's wishes to run the family farm. He loses the battle, as all good boys would, gets married, and takes up agrarian life. His switch to that lifestyle is jarring, and he becomes rapidly bitter and enraged essentially greed takes a hold of him, and he is unable to control himself in many respects. The story continues, largely focused on his housekeeper, Lakshmi (Azmi), and his relationship with her and the surrounding townspeople. His seemingly consistent life of exerting semi-torture and quasi-love for those he encounters is turned upside down when his wife finally arrives.The character of Lakshmi an young, largely oppressed by still happy worker is not at all unlike the realities of life in India (especially at that time). Benegal uses her exceptional beauty as a sort of scaffold for the viewer not only are we sympathetic to her social predicament, but we are because of who she is, her kind words and fidelity.The most powerful aspect of the film is the director's play on family dynamic, caste, and power. These themes are so interwoven and densely packed into the film, that it is hard to imagine it all coalescing so beautifully in just under two hours. Benegal's films, sometimes noted in the Indian 'New Wave' movement, are generally as such. There is no doubt that this movie has many aspects that are far ahead of its own time and far too advanced for the people who watched it when it was released.Benegal's ability to deal with such vital themes makes the movie all the more amazing. Of course, from a simple entertainment standpoint, the movie is rife with short humor and phenomenal close up shots. In fact, there are many off screen elements to the movie that throw hints at the viewer about what is happening; Benegal almost emulates the great Thomas Hardy, except in film.RATING: 10/10